Silent Film Intertitle vs Wayang Kulit

サイレント映画の字幕カード / ワヤン・クリ(影絵芝居)

Silent Film Intertitle comes from Film Technology and Wayang Kulit from Stage Design. One is technique and the other style. They are reached for with some of the same intent, which is where they get confused.

Silent Film Intertitle

Dialogue and description were cut into the film as separate cards of type. This is where cinema and typography first met.

Wayang Kulit

Javanese shadow theater works pierced leather puppets between a lamp and a screen, and in doing so perfected a formal language of contour, silhouette and the stylized profile.

Silent Film IntertitleWayang Kulit
Era1900s–1920straditional–present
FamilyFilm TechnologyStage Design
KindTechniqueStyle
CuesText cards on black / Ornamental frames / Hand lettering / Alternating rhythm with the actionPierced leather puppets / Stylized profiles / Shadow and light source / All-night performances
Best used forShort films watched without sound that need dialogue on separate cards · Chapter breaks and advertising borrowing the manner of the silent eraStage or screen work that must narrate with a lamp and a sheet · Character design reducing figures to profiles that repeat as signs
TypeDifferent faces for speech and narration, trimmed to fit one cardTreat letters as pierced holes, read from the leather left behind
CompositionCenter the text and keep even space on all four sidesProfiles ranged left and right, the center kept open for confrontation
MaterialWhite out of black, with a faint film weave and gate flickerPierce the hide to pass light, vary shadow density by rod angle
CautionCards that explain too much stop the flow every time they appear, and the film turns into something to be read rather than watched.Building the shadow as a plain black shape loses the information carried in the piercing, and nothing separates it from a cut-out silhouette.

IndexStyle