Kintsugi vs Mingei
金継ぎ / 民藝
Kintsugi comes from Vessel and Craft Techniques and Mingei from Craft Movements. One is technique and the other style. They are reached for with some of the same intent, which is where they get confused.
Kintsugi
%20-%20Flickr%20-%20dalbera.png)
Kintsugi is the Japanese craft of repairing broken ceramics with urushi lacquer and gold or silver, so the mend is shown rather than hidden. The Getty vocabulary files it under repairing, as a restorative process rather than a style. The break decides where the metal lines run, so one vessel can never produce the same drawing twice.
Mingei
Yanagi Sōetsu and his circle found 'the beauty of use' in the everyday wares of unnamed craftsmen. By making anonymity, repetition and utility the measure of healthy form, the movement became the bedrock of Japanese design thought.
| Kintsugi | Mingei | |
|---|---|---|
| Era | 15th century– | 1926– |
| Family | Vessel and Craft Techniques | Craft Movements |
| Kind | Technique | Style |
| Cues | Thin gold or silver lines that follow the break exactly / Line width that varies, widening into filled areas where a chip was lost / A trace of dark lacquer showing at the edge of the metal / Metal lines crossing the vessel's original painted decoration without regard for it | Anonymous craftsmanship / Form following use / The steadiness born of repetition / Local materials and hand habits |
| Best used for | Building a display where broken prototypes or stock are shown mended instead of discarded · Leaving a visible record of repair or revision on a product or a screen | Setting the form and the reachable price of everyday wares meant for daily use · Retail and presentation that make the maker and the region the subject |
| Type | Add no lettering, and let the metal lines share the surface with whatever marks the vessel already carries. | Minimal marking, wording that states the use rather than the maker |
| Composition | The break dictates the lines, so fit the fragments first and then decide how much metal each seam takes. | Favor forms that line up together and avoid one piece standing out |
| Material | Urushi lacquer joins and hardens the pieces, then gold or silver powder is laid over the seam. | Local materials and standing glazes, the same form made many times |
| Caution | Designing the gold lines before anything breaks places them where no stress runs, and the piece looks patterned rather than mended. | The moment individual authorship is asserted the premise of anonymity collapses, and what remains is expensive craft merely performing plainness. |