Editorial Collage vs Punk

エディトリアル・コラージュ / パンク

Editorial Collage comes from Publishing and Editing and Punk from Counterculture. One is technique and the other style. They are reached for with some of the same intent, which is where they get confused.

Editorial Collage

Editorial Collage — マイク・マクエイドの作品（mikemcquade.comより引用）Editorial Collage — 雑誌『СССР на стройке（建設中のソ連）』1935年8号のページ「地下鉄ができた」 — Wikimedia Commons / Public domainEditorial Collage — エル・リシツキー『СССР на стройке（建設中のソ連）』1934年6号 表紙 — Wikimedia Commons / Public domain

Layers fragments from different times and contexts, showing the editor's point of view before any explanation.

Punk

Punk — イギリスのパンク・ファンジン — Wikimedia Commons / CC0Punk — 1970年代のファンジン — Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0Punk — 1980年代末のパンク／アナルコ・ジャケット — Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

A DIY objection to the authority of the tidy, made by cutting, pasting and dirtying.

Editorial CollagePunk
Eracontemporary1970s–1980s
FamilyPublishing and EditingCounterculture
KindTechniqueStyle
CuesCut-out photographs / Mixed scales / Collision with white space / AnnotationsCut-and-paste letters / Photocopier noise / Handwriting / Ragged placement
Best used forImplying an article's argument in one image · Giving found material a new readingVoicing dissent against the rules · Giving events and communities a raw voice
TypeA disciplined text face with large pull quotesMix newsprint letters, handwriting and stamps
CompositionChoose the leading fragment; layer the rest before and behindDeliberate misalignment and overlap; disturb even the margins
MaterialPhotos, scraps, hand-drawn lines; leave the cut edges visibleCopier paper, tears, black plus a warning color
CautionDon't just add material. Be able to say what every fragment means.Borrowed rebellion is hollow. Decide what you are protesting first.

Put these two together

Publishing and Editing ／ Counterculture

IndexStyle